ibnu-musafir.com

Chapter of the book: Explanation of the Preface to the Tafsir of Ibnu Abi Hatim ar-Razi · Read as PDF

A Note on tafsir by Mere Opinion: tadabbur, istinbat and the Linguistic Meaning of the Qur'an

Incidentally, what was said above about interpretation by mere opinion (at-tafsiru bi-r-ra'y) does not mean, as many people today assume through a lack of knowledge of the tafsir narrations and the science of tafsir, that it is absolutely impermissible to say anything about an ayah of the Qur'an without citing a statement from the Salaf on it.

The scholars of the first four generations themselves, and also those after them within the first centuries of the Islamic calendar, repeatedly cited passages of the Qur'an without quoting a statement of a predecessor on them.

Here a distinction is made above all between the terms tafsir, tadabbur and istinbat. Tadabbur refers to reflecting and pondering deeply on a verse of the Qur'an. Istinbat, on the other hand, refers to deriving from a passage of the Qur'an a meaning that is not obvious. This includes, for example, rulings derived for new matters (nawazil) that had not yet arisen in that form at the time.

Apart from this, a large part of the Qur'an was clear to the Arabs of that time simply through their understanding of the language, as will be discussed in more detail later. Even today, at least the general meaning of a verse is often clear to an Arab (with a basic education) through his knowledge of the language.

These points show that a person may well quote a verse of the Qur'an and, for example, explain its general and linguistic meaning, without thereby falling into the blameworthy tafsir by mere opinion (at-tafsiru bi-r-ra'yi l-madhmum).

Rather, what matters in this context is that no one should try to understand the Qur'an through his own opinion alone, without having studied the relevant tafsir narrations, or before having studied them.

Tadabbur and istinbat are therefore not wrong or reprehensible in themselves. They are only to be rejected when they take place completely detached from the narrations of the Salaf, or are undertaken before one knows these narrations.

Someone who lacks this necessary prior knowledge of the narrations will inevitably contradict them at times. The problem is that most people today follow precisely this wrong method without even being aware of the problem, and this has led to numerous misunderstandings about the Qur'an and tafsir.