The Chain of Narration from as-Suddi
وَمَا ذَكَرْنَا فِيهِ عَنِ السُّدِّيِّ بِلَا إِسْنَادٍ فَهُوَ مَا:
حَدَّثَنَا أَبُو زُرْعَةَ ثنا عَمْرُو بْنُ حَمَّادِ بْنِ طَلْحَةَ ثنا أَسْبَاطٌ عَنِ السُّدِّيِّ.
And as for what we mention from as-Suddi without a chain of narration, it is:
What Abu Zur'ah narrated to us: 'Amr ibnu Hammad ibni Talhah reported to us: Asbat narrated to us from as-Suddi.
Here we see an example of a narration in which Ibnu Abi Hatim ar-Razi narrates from Abu Zur'ah ar-Razi. The short biographies at the beginning of this book have already mentioned that Abu Zur'ah was one of the author's most important teachers. In this narration, then, Abu Zur'ah is Ibnu Abi Hatim's shaykh, as he is in many other narrations in his Tafsir.
This narration, too, has a short chain. It is an “isnad thulathi”, that is, an isnad with three links. Abu Zur'ah, who was himself an Imam and one of the greatest scholars of “al-jarhu wa-t-ta'dil”, the science of narrators, thus narrates this hadith with only two people in the chain before him. The chain is therefore very short.
In this chain of narration, the tafsir is narrated from Isma'il ibnu 'Abdi r-Rahman ibni Abi Karimah as-Suddi, who also became known as “as-Suddi al-kabir”, the “greater” or “elder” Suddi. This distinguished him from Muhammad ibnu Marwan al-Kufi, the “lesser” or “younger” Suddi, who, unlike the greater Suddi, was regarded as weak in narration.
In general, as-Suddi al-kabir is meant unless something else is specified. The “lesser Suddi” lived later than the “greater” one and is not the one Ibnu Abi Hatim means here. If one looks at the lineage of the lesser Suddi, one finds that he was a descendant of the greater Suddi, namely his great-grandson.
The tafsir narrations of as-Suddi lose some of their strength because he passed on a collection of statements on tafsir that contained different chains of narration. As-Suddi mixed these narrations, but for the sake of brevity left out the isnad belonging to each individual narration.
Here, however, we see that Ibnu Abi Hatim regarded this isnad as acceptable enough to mention narrations through this route in his Tafsir – which does not necessarily mean that he would have treated it in the same way in classical hadith narration, for example.
As has been mentioned several times, such assessments by the early scholars were based on their comprehensive knowledge. They knew, then, that the narrations from a particular source were generally regarded as trustworthy by the scholars of their own time and of the generations before them, and that the interpretations agreed with the well-known and widespread interpretations.
These remarks should suffice here as a brief insight, since matters of this kind cannot be discussed in detail within the limited scope of this work.