Reasons Why tafsir and Other Fields of Knowledge Were Narrated in This Way
There are several reasons why tafsir and some other fields of knowledge were narrated in this way. Some of the important ones are mentioned below:
One reason is that tafsir was widely known among the Salaf through their constant study of and engagement with the Qur'an, since the knowledge of tafsir is closely connected with the Qur'an, which the Muslims diligently read, learned and taught.
The tafsir scholars specialized in their field and concentrated intensely on learning and passing on the interpretation of the Qur'an. For the most part, these interpretations were not statements of the Prophet صلى الله عليه وسلم himself, but statements of the Companions and of the generations that followed them. In narrating these interpretations, the scholars of tafsir were concerned primarily with the meanings and content, and less with the exact wording.
- The scholars passed these meanings on from one generation to the next. These interpretations and their meanings were known among the scholars throughout the vast Islamic empire of that time. Where there were differing opinions, these too were learned, taught and discussed. In any case, the common opinions were generally widespread and well known.
As mentioned, the scholars of tafsir were specialists in their field. Because of their focus on tafsir, they were often not necessarily scholars of the science of narration as well. Nevertheless, these sciences, too, are narrated knowledge.
The same applied to other fields of knowledge, such as the maghazi mentioned earlier and, above all, the sirah. A scholar could be regarded by the hadith scholars as “weak” with regard to his narration and his knowledge of chains of narration, while at the same time they attested that he was an Imam, that is, a leading scholar, in his own field. This happens frequently in the fields mentioned. The very same hadith scholars thus bore witness to the leading role of such people in their own fields and to the general correctness and authenticity of their statements in those fields.
Another example of this is the field of Qur'an recitation and its various readings (al-qira'ah / al-qira'at). Precisely because these scholars specialized in their field, they were often unable to acquire comprehensive knowledge of the chains of narration and the individual narrators. As already mentioned, however, this is not even necessary for passing on their knowledge, since these fields, such as the recitation of the Qur'an, were passed on through practice from one generation of scholars to the next. Chains of narration do exist in all these areas as well, and they have their benefit and importance, but as a support and corroboration, not as the sole basis on which narration rests.
Another reason is that the knowledge of tafsir was written down early on. The first comprehensive tafsir that has survived to this day is that of Muqatil ibnu Sulayman, who died in the middle of the second century, in 150 AH. Muqatil was classed as weak in hadith narration, but the content of his Tafsir was praised by some renowned scholars of the Salaf, who also made use of it. These scholars knew that Muqatil ibnu Sulayman's wording agreed with the well-known interpretations and did not contradict them. Muqatil's Tafsir covers the entire Qur'an. As already mentioned, this example shows that the tafsir of the Qur'an was recorded in writing at a very early stage. Its contents were thus widespread, known and accessible among the scholars from very early on.
The same is true of the tafsir of Mujahid ibnu Jabr. As already mentioned, Mujahid's interpretations have likewise largely survived to this day, though not as a single work, but in the books of later mufassirin, such as Ibnu Abi Hatim and at-Tabari, who frequently narrate from Mujahid.
- Much of the content of tafsir was narrated in the same way by several tafsir scholars. The different statements support one another, which is why it would be absurd to reject every single narration outright because it contains moderate weaknesses.
- It should be noted that the weaknesses in chains of narration differ. A weakness can be very serious. On the other hand, there are also narrators with very minor weaknesses, such as occasionally confusing one thing with another. The renowned scholars of tafsir and other fields deliberately did not narrate from people with very pronounced weaknesses. For this reason, these scholars avoided, for example, people who were known as liars or were accused of lying. Muhammad ibnu s-Sa'ib al-Kalbi has already been mentioned above as a well-known example of this.
Another important reason why tafsir was often not narrated with flawless chains of narration is that the interpretation of the Qur'an is often connected with the Arabic language. It has already been made clear that a large part of the meanings of the Qur'an was understood by the early Arabs simply through their understanding of the language. Even where the meaning of a passage could not be fully grasped through the Arabic language alone, it was nevertheless built upon it.
These linguistic meanings were handed down together with the Qur'an, just as the Arabic language itself was. This shows that not all sciences can be narrated with chains of narration, just as there is no chain of narration for every word of the language. Nevertheless, there is no doubt that this is the original Arabic language.
Especially in our time, one sees a growing tendency to search for weaknesses in early tafsir narrations and then to reject them on that basis. Yet it is absurd for someone to dismiss a linguistic interpretation by a Companion, even one that was narrated with a chain of narration, and then to rely on the explanation in a dictionary that has no chain at all!
Moreover, such a statement by a Companion was made with specific reference to the particular expression in the Qur'an. Those early scholars’ understanding of the language and of the context of the text in question was incomparably better. It is grotesque to dismiss this understanding, then to turn to an explanation in a dictionary that is independent of the Qur'anic text, and then even to apply it to the Qur'an with one's own deficient understanding of language and context!
Many tafsir narrations were passed on not individually but in written collections known as nusakhu t-tafsir. These writings can be recognized today by the fact that many narrations are traced back to a scholar with the same isnad.
Different standards of authenticity always applied to such written collections, because in passing on a written work the narrator's general integrity must certainly be established, but no ability to reproduce the individual texts from memory is required. The nusakh of tafsir were well known among the scholars at that time, and the scholars relied on those collections that they regarded as trustworthy after comparing them with other narrations and collections.
This also strongly corroborates the authenticity of tafsir narrations in general, since the written collections show how well known and widespread the teaching of tafsir was among the scholars of that time. These were by no means isolated narrations that had to be brought to light from obscurity. Quite the opposite: there were well-known schools with numerous renowned scholars who, besides their teachers, could draw on well-known written collections. Clearly, this does not mean that every collection or every single narration must therefore be regarded as beyond doubt. But in general, and especially in the case of written collections that the eminent scholars and specialists regarded as authentic and therefore relied on in their works, this point carries great weight.